^^^ Seriously, SAO is your first anime? Don;t get me wrong, it's definitely not bad and I really like the voice actors and the storyline set-up. There's a lot of good anime out there though, covering almost all genres imaginable.. think of some crazy situation that would make for an interesting story, your bound to find it. Yu-gi-oh Classic? Eh, that's pushing it a bit.. Don't get me wrong.. loved it as a kid, and I'd probably still watch it for novelty.. card battling was awesome at one time, but there's plenty more out there beyond that.
As I've stated before, I got into anime from watching Gundam Wing, DBZ, Yu Yu Hakusho, Cowboy Bebop, Inyuasha, Pilot Canidate (can someone please tell me where to find this online.. remember watchin a few episodes as a kid and that's it).. Evangelion was around then too, but I don't think I had the understanding to properly grasp it. Nowadays, I've watched so many animes over the years, I'd be lucky to name 60% of them.. But I will say that on the whole, 80-85% of them were enjoyable.